Toaster’s Contribution - I’ve been sitting on this
review for over a week now. It’s been hard to figure out exactly what I want to
say. I absolutely loved this movie. It was funny, moving, thought-provoking and
genius. Once again, Joaquin Phoenix proved that he is one of the most
underrated actors today, especially when you consider how vastly different his
character was in Her versus his eccentric and disturbed role in 2012’s The Master. In speaking of The Master, Amy Adams was also
in both that film and Her. I was disappointed that Adams’
husband in Her wasn’t played by Philip Seymour Hoffman. We could have had a
Master reunion! (They could have also invited director Paul Thomas Anderson to
bring unnerving silences between their lines of dialogue!)
I have to spotlight Spike Jonze, the writer and director of
Her. I already thought the man was a crazy genius after his amazing music
videos and expectation shattering films such as Being John Malkovich. However, after seeing his newest film, I am
in awe of his talent. He created a future world that is really only a few years
away and already feels real. In a quirky but genuine manner, Her explores the
very notion of love, what it means to be in a romantic relationship and poses
the question of what it means to be human.
The film, however, delves even deeper than existential
concepts of love and interaction. Jonze sets the stage for something that could
really happen. By placing advanced artificial intelligence, designed to learn
as it interacts, programmers set into motion what many scientists have termed
“the singularity.” For those unfamiliar with the theory, the idea is that computers
steadily become smarter, faster and more powerful with each advancement of
technology, which in turn leads to the next advancement. This technological
growth continues to multiply exponentially until such a point that computers
become more intelligent than man can ever hope to be. At that point the future
of the human race becomes uncertain, not unlike trying to figure out what lies
beyond the event horizon of a black hole (or singularity). Science fiction has
delved into this concept before, usually in an ‘end of the world’ manner (i.e.
Skynet from the Terminator franchise).
In fact, this year a film entitled Transcendence, starring Johnny Depp, is set
to be released that explores the singularity theory; though by the look of the
trailer, the movie seems to be focused on spookiness and inexplicable scenes of
things floating in the air in what looks to be yet another Inception rip-off. (This leads me to believe that rather than
providing us with an interesting vision of a possible future; it’s just going
to be a silly mess.)
My point is that I think Her is very likely a more accurate
depiction of how the singularity could come about and some of the effects it
has on the human race, though that theme is downplayed into a seamless
background subplot amidst Phoenix’s Theodore Twombley and his ever evolving
relationship with his operating system Samantha. (Oddly, Scarlett Johansson had
more of a presence in this film than she did in Don Jon, where she was physically present!) You see the world
gradually change around him. People are seen holding conversations with their
phones. As more and more people begin having romantic relationships with their
operating systems, at first on just an emotional and psychological level, then
later in a bizarre physical manner, as the opinions of society become divided
over acceptance of these relationships versus disgust at something so
unorthodox… a clever wink at the current debate of homosexuality in our
culture!
Prior to seeing Her, I had read some critical observations
of the film (from somebody who hadn’t even seen the movie). I forget from where
or whom, but the gist of it was Her was unoriginal because it was “ripping off”
the premise of an episode of The Big Bang
Theory in which one of the characters falls in love with Siri, the vocal
search engine on iPhones. First of all,
while I have never seen that episode, I doubt that the sitcom delved so deeply
into the very concepts of relationships and what it means to be in love, let
alone the scope of character interactions and the changing world. Second, Spike
Jonze has a history of taking on unoriginal projects and turning them into
something completely unique. For instance, look what he did with the beloved
book Where the Wild Things Are. He
took a children’s classic and turned it into an amazing film about growing up
and the end of innocence! Or how about Adaptation?
What was supposed to be a straight up movie based on the book The Orchid Thief
was turned into a bizarre film written by Charlie Kaufman and directed by Spike
Jonze!
I don’t want to give away anything more about the plot. I
just want everyone to go see this unconventional yet sincere science fiction
masterpiece. Her is easily one of, quite possibly the best movie I saw
in 2013 (though I didn’t get around to it until this year!)
And now comes the long
and rambling thoughts on the film by Jonny Prophet… or he’s just a deeply
disturbed individual; history will be the judge!
Jonny’s Contribution - I was deeply moved by this
movie. Spike Jozne proves he’s one of the best directors today. It is a
fantastic movie about human relationships and humanity itself. But I don’t
believe it will win any awards and that’s shame. I think people miss the
point of this movie based on what previews showed. I hope Spike Jonze will make
a new film soon.
(I think this is the
point where the pills started to kick in… or stop working. Seriously, who can
tell with this guy?)
I can’t wait for that new Wes Anderson film to come out. Seriously,
why isn’t there a mass transit system in middle earth, do people like walking
there? Dammit Michael B. Jordan, stop wasting your talent on rom-coms!
That goes double for you Anthony Mackie! Based on the trailers the new X-men
film is going suck. It’s like a train wreck that you can’t help but watch, but
it’s full of mutants! What the hell is up with Quicksilver? I’m glad the Burger
King Kids Club mascot has found work!... Oh right back to talking about the movie Her.
I deeply look forward to a future with bullet trains, smart OS’s, and people
that hand write letters to your family on your behalf, or you know… Japan. But then
Pharrell made a 24 hours music video! Who has the time to watch this? I could
only get 2 hours of it done. Also he looked like Smoky the Bear at Grammys this
year. How heck did we end up with a bear as fire safety mascot and Brits get a
frog for theirs? Bears don’t really say fire safety to me… a chipmunk
maybe. Why is Steve Guttenberg not more movies? Do think the studio will
make a sequel to Her that’s written and directed by someone else, starting Zach
Braff as a plucky programmer? I might see it if Turk is voice of OS in that one
or maybe Doctor Cox. Oh well, it would be nice if my computer talked me
with voice Scarlett Johansson… instead of an angry man that speaks only in
Portuguese.
Thanks for that time stolen from my life that I will never get back, Jonny. Until the next review (something nice and depressing with a good soundtrack) Stay Strange!
This was totally a man-date. He brought you flowers!
ReplyDelete